Compare / PFAS treatment

PFAS destruction vs. carbon and ion exchange

Capture moves PFAS to a new waste stream. Destruction ends it.

Short answer

Granular activated carbon (GAC) and ion exchange (IX) resin capture PFAS from water onto media. The PFAS is not destroyed. It stays on the spent media, which then has to be handled and disposed of. Olift® foam fractionation concentrates PFAS into a small volume, and Obreak® electro-oxidation destroys it onsite, breaking it down to carbon dioxide and fluoride ions.

The difference
Operator beside ion exchange columns at a PFAS treatment site

Capture is not destruction

Common treatments for removing PFAS from water include separation (reverse osmosis) and adsorption (granular activated carbon or ion exchange resin). These approaches capture PFAS from water into a reverse osmosis concentrate or into PFAS-contaminated media.

The result is a PFAS waste stream that has to be dealt with separately. That adds cost and risk, and the PFAS is still there at the end.

Side by side

How the two approaches compare

GAC and ion exchangeOlift® foam fractionation and Obreak® electro-oxidation
What it does with PFASCaptures PFAS onto carbon or resinConcentrates PFAS with foam, then destroys it by electro-oxidation
End state of the PFASRemains on the spent mediaCarbon dioxide and fluoride ions
Waste left to manageSpent media for disposal or regenerationA small foamate volume, generally 1% to 10% of the influent, treated onsite
Where the PFAS ends upOffsite, after the media leaves the plantDestroyed at the site
Strong fitLower-strength water that is otherwise cleanHigh-strength and difficult streams such as RO concentrate, landfill leachate and AFFF-impacted water
DeliveryVessels and media changeoutsContainer, trailer or fixed installation, continuous and remotely monitored

Performance of any adsorption media depends on the PFAS present, competing compounds and water chemistry. A pilot on your own water is the reliable way to compare.

>99.5%

of regulated PFAS removed from 106,000 gallons of fire training water at Hobart International Airport with Olift® foam fractionation

93%

of total PFAS removed from landfill leachate at the Passaic Valley Sewerage Commission pilot

94 to 96%

of the concentrated PFAS destroyed by Obreak® electro-oxidation in that same pilot

In practice
Obreak electro-oxidation reactors installed on a plant floor

Better together, not either-or

Destruction does not have to replace every other step. The E2METRIX® approach is a toolbox: concentrate upstream with Olift® foam fractionation, destroy with Obreak® electro-oxidation, then finish with a media polishing step downstream.

Concentrating first matters. Olift® foam fractionation raises PFAS concentration in the feed by 100x to 10,000x, so the destruction step sees a small, strong stream and needs far less capital and energy.

FAQ

Carbon and ion exchange questions

What is the difference between PFAS capture and PFAS destruction?

Capture moves PFAS from the water onto a solid or into a concentrate. Destruction breaks the PFAS apart. Obreak® electro-oxidation breaks it down to carbon dioxide and fluoride ions.

What happens to PFAS captured by carbon or resin?

It stays on the media. The spent media has to be disposed of or regenerated, which creates a PFAS waste stream that must be dealt with separately.

Can Olift® foam fractionation and Obreak® electro-oxidation replace carbon or ion exchange?

For concentrated and difficult streams such as RO concentrate, landfill leachate and AFFF-impacted water, yes, and the PFAS is destroyed onsite. Many treatment trains still use a media polishing step at the end. An E2METRIX engineer can review your water and recommend the right mix.

Does destruction leave anything behind?

The end products of electro-oxidation are carbon dioxide and fluoride ions, both harmless at low concentrations. Olift® foam fractionation leaves a small concentrate volume that goes straight to Obreak® electro-oxidation.

How do I compare the options for my site?

Run a pilot on your water. Contact E2METRIX to talk with an engineer about your water, your limits and a pilot plan. See pilots and the case studies.

Tell us about your site

Send us your flow and PFAS concentrations. An E2METRIX engineer will reply within 24 hours.